Go to the Students section
Go to the Staff section
Go to the Alumni section
Go to the Study here section
Go to the International section
Go to the About section
Go to the Research section
Go to the Business and Employers section
Go to the Support us section
David Palfreyman, Susan Jones Zayed University, Dubai
Tuesday 4 September 2007, 10.10-11.10
In this research seminar we will present for discussion preliminary findings from a research project on student collaboration both within and outside the formal framework of university courses.
Student collaboration in any university has two faces: formalized groupwork/teamwork, and informal collaboration. Each of these can vary in its quality, so that "student collaboration" may include effective or ineffective groupwork projects, ad hoc peer assistance, informal study groups and simple copying/cheating.
Collaborative learning is often proposed as an effective teaching and learning approach (Lizzio and Wilson, 2006; Delucchi, 2006; Hancock, 2004; Summers et al., 2005), and teamwork skills are seen as contributing to employability and lifelong learning (Government of Ontario, 2007; University of Melbourne, 2007). Recently there has been increasing focus on the processes of collaborative learning (Kumpulainen and Kaartinen, 2003) and on the contexts within which collaborative learning is promoted (Strom and Strom, 2002). There is another body of literature on various kinds of cheating/copying (Williams, 2001; Eisenberg, 2004; Hutton, 2006), often with reference to students' cultural background (Robinson & Kuin, 1999; Selsky, 2000; Lupton and Chapman, 2002). Barrett and Cox (2005) investigated student and staff perceptions, and point out that the distinction is often unclear between collaboration and collusion. Students are encouraged to collaborate, but only up to a point, and only in certain ways and contexts.
In our context (Zayed University, Dubai) the cultural dimension is particularly interesting because the teachers at the University are mainly Western, while the students are Gulf Arab women from a fairly traditional educational background, for whom mutual help (or at least the appearance of it) is a core cultural value. However we know from debates in wider forums that similar issues are of relevance in universities worldwide.
Our research project is investigating the following questions:
We categorize collaboration on two dimensions, to form four types: teacher-initiated in class (e.g. group discussion), teacher-initiated outside class (e.g. group assignments), student-initiated in class (e.g. asking one's neighbour a question) and student-initiated out of class (e.g. informal study groups).
The first stage of the research involved interviewing a sample of 21 students from a range of specializations, using a semi-structured format to elicit their perceptions of the collaborative experiences that they have had during their university career. At the time of submitting this abstract, the transcribed interviews are being analyzed, in order to ascertain students' attitudes to collaboration with other students, and the constructs which they use to interpret collaborative experiences. Examples of constructs emerging from the interviews are 'personal responsibility' and 'networks of mutual help'.
The next stage of the research (to be completed by June 2007) involves preparing an online survey based on constructs and perceptions discovered in the interviews, and gaining responses to this survey from 200-300 students in different departments in our university. We will then analyze the responses in order to identify overall trends in the sample, as well as correlations, for example between students' responses to formal and to informal collaboration, and between these and the students' level and specialization.
In the seminar we will share data and conclusions from the research to date, and we hope to gain the perspectives of those from other university contexts, and to stimulate discussion about, among other things, how staff and students can be made more aware of the issues involved, and how collaborative work can be made more effective.