The role of the Appeals Process and Panel
Colleagues may appeal the outcome of their application for progression to Senior Lecturer if there is evidence of procedural irregularity or discrimination i.e. the way in which the application was considered led to a decision that was not reasonable in the circumstances.
The Appeals Panel will consist of a senior member of the People Directorate (normally the Deputy Director, People Operations) and a thematic Pro Vice-Chancellor.
The panel will not consider any new evidence to further support the initial application for progression to Senior Lecturer.
Eligibility
Colleagues wishing to appeal must meet the following criteria:
- The unsuccessful application was submitted as part of the most recent set of applications for progression.
- Panel feedback has been discussed with their line manager, the Head of School and a member of the Senior Lecturer Progression Panel.
- Colleagues are able to provide evidence that process applied led to an unreasonable decision.
Making an Appeal
To appeal, colleagues must complete the Senior Lecturer Progression Appeal Form (Brookes login required, this form will open in August), clearly detailing:
- The reason for appeal.
- Evidence to support the appeal, including evidence of the procedural irregularity or discrimination that led to an unreasonable outcome.
The Appeal Form must be submitted by email to the Reward and Recognition Manager within 14 calendar days of the date of the letter giving the decision of the Senior Lecturer Progression Panel.
The Appeals Panel
A panel consisting of the Deputy Director, People Operations (or other senior colleague from the People Directorate), and a thematic Pro Vice-Chancellor will review:
- The initial application for promotion, including supporting statements.
- The feedback from the Senior Lecturer Progression Panel.
- The Appeal Form and the evidence submitted in support of it.
The role of the appeals panel is to identify whether there has been a procedural irregularity or discrimination and the impact of this on the initial outcome. The panel will:
- Seek any further information they need in order to make a full and fair assessment.
- Determine whether any action should be taken as a result of their assessment, including whether the appellant should progress to Senior Lecturer.
Outcomes
The Appeals Panel will normally meet and provide an outcome within 30 working days from the date of receipt of the Appeal Form.
If the appeal is successful, and if the Appeal Panel determines that the appellant should progress to Senior Lecturer, that progression will be backdated as if the original application had been successful.
If the appeal is unsuccessful i.e the panel outcome is upheld, feedback will be provided. This decision will conclude the appeals process. There is no further right to appeal or to raise a grievance concerning the process or outcome.